Now, if the specialty of Dubinsky-"Pokhmury" is unequivocally established behind his posts and confirmed by his friend Ivan Okhlobistin, it is possible to conduct an additional analysis of the role of Dubinsky in the transport of "Buka 332" on April 17, 2014 at the exit of Ukraine. In our analysis, it is shown that Dubinsky Buv key the organizer of the transportation of "Buka 332" from Donetsk to the fields on the day from Snizhny on the day of the tragedy. In addition, this analysis confirms the validity of overblown telephone conversations involving Dubinsky, published by the SBU on April 18, 2014. The deyakі podrobitsі tsikh eavesdropping earlier were unreasonable, or they were put under sumnіv - for example, the riddle of beaten litakіv and "Carnation" at the rose of Dubinsky and Boatswain. A more detailed analysis allows confirming the most important details of these links by looking at the conclusions.

In the upcoming sections, a short description of the reports of the analysis of five links for the participation of Sergiy "Khmuriy" Dubinsky, published by the SBU and the International Investigative Group, as well as additional comments on some of the details, which should be taken from the greater version with the option of one link, is added.

Dubinsky at the wiretapping of telephone calls published by the SBU

Interfering with telephone conversations, as the Security Service of Ukraine (SBU) noticed, important details of Dubinsky's role in the transport of Buka 332 on April 17, 2014. On the day after the attack, the SBU identified Khmuriy as “Petrovsky Sergiy Mykolayovich, born in 1964, officer of the GRU of the General Staff of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation, intercessor of Igor Girkin (“Strilok”) from the investigation, at the time of the overthrow he had been with Donetsk.” At once, we see that some details and identifications are incorrect and inaccurate - for example, the river of the people (1962, not 1964) is that nickname (Dubinsky, and not “Petrovsky” - it’s a pseudonym for the “DPR”). In addition, in the description of one of the interlopers, the SBU pardoned the information from the front line (div. "Zmist of the fifth ring"). In addition, the SBU published the number of the hacked phone: +38 063 121 3401. Published hacks are available on the SBU channel with comments Ukrainianі English language. Dubinsky's voice on the video present on the badges 1:33 - 3:52 , 4:15 - 5:22 .

Zmist of the first call (9:08):

At the first hour of the first call, Dubinsky roams with "Buryatik" - a separatist, whose specialty was never established. "Buryatik" asks Dubinsky ("Pokhmury"), where they want to install the "Buk-M1" installation ("Buryatik" calls it "beautiful", "Buk", "B" and "M"), they brought wine from an unidentified city to Donetsk . Asking, de zavantazhiti and stealing "Buk", which arrived on the trawl, "Buryatik" confirmed to Dubinsky that the "Buk" arrived from the crew. Dubinsky confirms "Buryatik" that the installation does not need to be rozvantazhuvaty and hovati, because it can destroy "there" already at once.

Analysis

• The hour of the first call (9:08 am) should be directed at English version of the SBU video, as well as at video MSG on 30 March 2015.
• It’s not clear that the “crew” of the installation came from Russia, that it was a group of separatist fighters, that it was a Russian-separatist crew.
• Divination by Dubinsky, the point of recognition is probably, the field for the first day in the Snowy hour is in the middle of the night, the stars of the month are transferred to cover the PPO. The victory of the PPO in this region would be logical, but the Ukrainian air force constantly hit the Snizhny region. The most noticeable was an airstrike on the 15th lime, after which 12 civil accidents perished. In addition, a Su-25 aircraft (coordinates 47.857925, 38.79837) can be seen on the satellite image from 16 lime 2014.
• On the video published on 30 March 2015 International lead group є more a few seconds of the same call (reporting div. for example, stats).

Change of another call (9:22):

At another telephone ring, which the video starts at 2:12, Dubinsky is moving again with Buryatik. We ask that Buryatik brought one or two Buk installations. "Buryatik" explains that in the course of the transfer of the installations "it went unreasonably", the shards of another vehicle for the transportation of the "Buk" were not known. "Vony" lured "Buk" from the trawl, to which yogo they brought, after which the "Buk" overturned the "wife" (tobto cordon) under its own power, and then we got bogged down on the next trawl and drove to Donetsk. Let's remember Dubinsky as "Buryatik", that "Buk" before the month was recognized with tanks by the "Skhid" battalion.

Analysis

• The hour of the call (9:22 a.m.) is aimed at English version of the SBU video.
• Dubinsky ochіkuvav, scho to hand over one more car - I did not understand myself. It is possible, with the help of the increase in the number of visnovoks, that Dubinsky helped to coordinate the transfer of that “Buk” version, the shards of information about those that would be staged by itself, and “Buryatik”, knowing that behind the vkazіvki, where to transport the Buk, they should turn themselves up to Dubinsky.
• I didn’t fully understand how the situation was described by “Buryatik” with the words “they went unaware there”. Possibly, having checked, that another transport vehicle will take away another Buk, otherwise the stinks themselves will remove part of the transport.
• I don’t know who could think of getting away from “them”, that they brought the Buk to the cordon from the Russian side. “Buryatik” does not give details, but we know that the “stinks” were in contact with the separatists, among them there could be members of the crew (divine analysis of previous negotiations) and the “stinks” transported the Buk to the cordon.
• Unbeknownst, de same "Buk" passed through the "husband", and de from the Ukrainian side of the cordon, parked the trailer. Nayimovіrnіshim є point of illegal crossing of the cordon between n.p. Pivnichniy (Ukraine) and Donetsk (Russia) at coordinates 48.352967, 39.942758. Report div. dopovіdі Bellingcat «Buk. Krapka zbіrki” that side. 11-13 update Bellingcat "Russia on the steps of war".
• In an interview with the separatist ZMI icorpus, who, having pinned the duty, induced in the vicinity of Anatoly "El-Murid" Nesmyan, Dubinsky Zgadu, that shortly before the death of MH17, having taken off, he allowed to take 3-4 tanks from the battalion "Skhid": " ... if I went to Stepanivka, before the Boeing disaster, I phoned Khodakovsky, I didn’t ask Igor Ivanovich [Girkin-"Strelkov"], but me, and said: "If you need it, you can take 3-4 tanks from me."I took what I needed» .
• The transfer of Buk and tanks to the descent took place not so well, like letting Dubinsky go. Arnold Greydanus and blogger [email protected](Div. also) resolutely analyzed the movement of the colony "Skhodu" for the same route, as well as "Buk", but at another hour. Below are two videos of the column "Skhodu":

Zmist of the third call (9:23):

At one o'clock on the third call (at 2:43 on the video) Dubinsky roams with the other partner - "Sanich". The SBU introduced Yogo Yak DPR fighter, Khmuriy's intercessor. At Rozmov Dubinsky, Sanich is told that “Because of your feet, my Buk-M”, how to be on the trawl. Vin feed "Sanich", "... where do you go, put a column at the column?". Sanich seems that the column is being formed "beyond Motelevsky Kіlts".

Analysis

• The hour of the call (9:23 wound) is aimed at English version of the SBU video.
• "Buk 332" the next hour of parking near the Motelevskiy kіltsya (as you can see on this video from the car), and then straight to the exit through Makіїvka ( video), Zugres ( video), Torez (photo) and Snizhne ( video).
• Tsikavo, that Dubinsky calls the installation "Buk" "mine", that I again point out to those who were the key organizers of the transportation of the installation from Russia.
• The key fragment of the over-the-top negotiations: it is clear from them that the different separatists were small in different instructions. Here Dubinsky does not know where to transport the "Buk 332", to "put it in a column", but he knows the first point of recognition and what can be drunk with the "Skhodu" tanks.

Zmist of the fourth call (9:54):

Dubinsky is talking about another unidentified person, as it is presented exclusively as a “DPR terrorist”. Dubinsky would tell the clerk to telephone people with the positive “Librarian” and show that the clerk knows “himself knows what” beyond Motelevsky Kilz. The person has not been identified, confirming that he knows what to put on the street and “you know what”. Potim Dubinsky orders you to take it “... it’s only quiet there, you turned around, you need some help for support. Leave the reshta here.” Dali Dubinsky seems to go to the area of ​​​​the settlement of Pervomaisk, as I tell you to know on the map. When you arrive before the May Day failures, you may be afraid to take a position and bring there “your own, who is in you.” Yogo zavdannya - reserve and defense of the Buk installation. Dubinsky completes Rozmov’s riddle, that a person from the positive “Gyurza” will also arrive at the position.

Analysis

• The hour of the call (9:54 wound) is aimed at English version of the SBU video.
• No one has ever been able to unambiguously establish the person of the “Librarian”. Somebody has done a great deal of food, protested no one so and not given a new instilled opinion. The deyakı admitted that vin is a Russian military, possibly a rozvіdnik, prote nіhto without specifying a specific person. Others pointed to Fyodor Berezin, a huge Russian PPO officer, whom the New Yorker called "Russian Tom Clancy" for his sci-fi and Russian books. 2014 year Berezin became the intercessor of the Minister of Defense of the "DNR". Prote nevidomo, chi having changed Berezin at Donetsk for an hour. Judging by the posts in Yogo LiveJournal, in a moment, you can talk to Lugansk. With this, it is impossible to unequivocally confirm that the "Bibliotekar" is bound by books that are illuminated people. For example, “librarian” is the name of the monster from the popular book and game universe “Metro 2033”, the stars of the “Sparta” battalion of Arseniy “Motoroli” Pavlov took their emblem. The establishment of the specialty of the Librarian to allow the selection of the most important meals, connected with the overflowing MH17.
• It is not clear who Dubinsky herself may be on the verge of “they turned around”, but it’s possible to go about the fighters of Girkin, as if they came from the Slovyanskaya post of the bagatomisiachnaya oblog less than two days before the battle of MH17. These people, maybe, were small for a great battle dosvid, nizh those who were in Donetsk and nearby places.
• People who talk about Dubinsky are sing-song, the very ones who accompanied Buk 332 from Donetsk to Snizhny. Prote, at the time of arrival to Snizhny, not all of their cars were left in the column. For example, on a video taken from Makiivtsi in the 11th rank area, The installation is accompanied by a black Peugeot 3008, a UAZ-469 jeep, a Toyota RAV4 2010 cira with a modified spoiler and a dark blue Volkswagen minibus. On the video from Snizhny, rented for a year before the battle, the Buk is accompanied by only one car.
• There are two settlements with a name similar to Pervomaisk near the city, the Buk 332 launching a missile that hit MH17. Closer to the start of the launch, the settlement of Pervomaiska is roztashovan, and less than in one field on the pivnich from the outside is the village of Pervomaisk. It’s impossible to talk about them Dubinsky, prote mizh village Pervomaisky and the start-up knew the checkpoint of the separatists, to talk about those who were on the vіn maw on the way to the very population point.
• Reliably establish the specialty of "Gyurzi" smoothly, the shards are worth adding extensions to the positive. Ymovirno, he was Dubinsky’s intercessor at the “DPR rozvіdtsі”. In 2015, the Novaya Gazeta newspaper wrote that Gyurza had previously served in the French Foreign Legion, but the protest statement did not come close to confirming.

The fifth of that rest of Rozmov was born on the eve of the day of 17 April 2014 to rock and was born between Dubinsky and “Boatswain”, which the SBU calls an officer of the Russian GRU. Dubinsky told the Boatswain that he was going “on Marynivtsi” and that “he couldn’t do it better” at the new one. I explain that the stinks are constantly stoking the Gradiv fire, and they recently shot down a Ukrainian Su-25 aircraft. Vіn zgaduє, scho yogo forces of the vrants got "Buk-M", after which "it became easier". Dubinsky dodaє that Ukrainian soldiers are trying to get out of Zelenopill, but for whom it is necessary for them to break through the soldiers of Dubinsky. Vin also knows that “on the 16th lime” the stench shot down two Su-25s, and today one. For example, move Dubinsky, it seems that “in two years” they are going to Donetsk, where three “Carnations” are minted on the new one. We are going to transport them "here" to the area of ​​Marynivka.

Analysis

• The hour of rozmovy vozvaniya like 9:08 am, and Dubinsky, according to the description, is found near Donetsk. It is obvious that they are no longer viable. The SBU could sing-songly copied the explanation to the first call, replacing “Buryatik” with “Boatswain”. Dubinsky clearly points to the name of the link that is found in Marynivtsi. Rozmova is waking up already after that, like Buk beating letak. The exact hour of the call is not clear, but it singsongly sounded late in the day or early in the evening after the MH17 crash, before it became known that the passenger liner had been hit.

• The person of "Botswain" has never been established. At the same time, in a post on Glav.su for December 13, 2015, Dubinsky made a lot of people out of such positive. Vіn zgaduє "Boatswain", the strong defender of Bezler, the second, the strong protector of the commander of the 3rd brigade from Horlivka, and the third, who served with the DPR battalion "Viking". Three of them are the first - the most important participant in the overswept rozmovi.
• Not long before the downing of MH17, important battles took place near the Marynivka area. On the 16th lime, on the day before the clash, a video appeared, to which Igor "Strilkov" Girkin and Oleksandr Borodai were going to the field for a beer stop in Stepanivka and talking about the battles in the Marynivka region. The video shows the Strila-10 anti-aircraft missile system. The forces of the separatists went to Marynivka on the 17th day of the fall. It was reported that part of the village stench was filled with 16 lindens.

• You can often put it in, Dubinsky talks about how to beat (or poshkodzhen) letaki. Vіn zgaduє, scho on the day before the day before the stink of the stench hit two "Sushki" (Su-25). On the 16th, close to 13:00, two Su-25s were actually hit, and only one of them was hit. testify to those that Su-25s fired strikes near the Saur-Mogila area, that was for a kilometer in the launch of the fatal Buk missile, the village of Marinivka that city, de Strelkov gave an interview on the aphids of the anti-aircraft missile system. Dubinsky was merciful, saying that on the day of the call they beat another "Sushka". The only flight that killed that day was the Boeing MH17 of the Malaysian Airlines.
• Dubinsky was talking about three “Carnations” in the distance: all three self-propelled guns 2S1 “Carnations” without identification signs and numbers that passed from Luhansk to Donetsk on April 15, 2014. The column, which included three "Carnations" in the yak, repeatedly ate that video in the photo (div. Bellingcat investigation). Three "Carnations" churned out on the 15th lime near 19:00 near the center of Donetsk. The same cars (UAZ-469, Toyota RAV4 2010 and a dark blue Volkswagen minibus) accompanied the Buk 332 on 17 lines. Evenings of the same day (judging from the riddle about the “Sushki” beats, even after the death of MH17) Dubinsky sang from Marynivka to Donetsk. That same night, three "Carnations" broke from Donetsk to Marynivka. Judging by the reports, three "Carnations" hovered at the exit from Donetsk at noon from 17 to 18 lime.

Once again I apologize, it’s important for me to control myself at once.

Krigolam Hetman (@YevhenS)

I live together with my family in the Rostov region, at a good-looking house on the farm of Veliky Log. Ride on an expensive Canadian quad bike, maybe a village of ten hundred acres, it’s possible, like earlier, to love drinking - judges for the front place of living gave Dubinsky the honor of P’yany Roger. To sing-songly love the memories he passed through Afghanistan and Chechnya. The life of a human being has less than one day, about which one is unlikely to be spoken of by unknown people: July 17, 2014, the day of the Boeing-777 crash of the Malaysian Airlines near Donetsk.

On April 18, after the tragedy, as it took away life 298 cases, the Security Service of Ukraine published a record of a telephone call, as if it was supposed to be true of the Ukrainian special services, close to the 9th anniversary of the morning of the 17th century. On the recording, midway through, a little voice of two people, in the credits the names of their names - "Pokhmury" and "Buryat". "Buryat" feed, kudi yoma "vantazhity beautiful", yaku vin "brought well to Donetsk". "Pokhmury" vіdpovіdaє: "Tse those, what am I thinking about?" - "So, Buk, Buk" - confirms Yogo Zdogad "Buryat". I’ll discuss even more for a sprat of khvilin “Pokhmury” with the other lieutenant, “Sanich”, where it is necessary to deliver the rocket launcher. Otrimavshi instructions, vіn robbing one more call to one of his pіdleglih: "Look at the map, Pervomaisk. Here in that area it's growing.
In two years, this phone call will become one of the main pieces of evidence in the materials of the prosecutor's office of the Netherlands in the International Investigative Group about the reasons for the Boeing crash. The main version of the international group was and remains unchanged: they were shot down from the territory, as if they were controlled by the separatists, from the Buk-M1 rocket launcher, brought from Russia. These versions are supplemented by the authors of numerous independent investigations, and only official Moscow, having presented to the court the vast majority of dozens of mutually exclusive versions, like before, categorically rebut my accountability to tragedy.
Zavdyaki vodkritim dzherelam, we are in front of photographs and videos at social networks, at once we know about the road "Buku" from Russia to Ukraine mayzhe everything. V_domy and a number of people, one of those moments, pressed the button to launch the rocket that day. Now, as it seems to its new research expert from the independent group Bellingcat, it is enough to add one more person, attributed to the Boeing crash, that very Pokhmury. He appeared as a Russian military professional, professional breeder Sergiy Mikolayovich Dubinsky, who for a long time changed for different positive names and nicknames, and also forged the nickname "Petrovsky".

In the past, after the Boeing disaster, Pokhmury appeared in the public space in the autumn of the same fate. On April 18, the pro-Kremlin website Politrussia.ru published a great interview with "Colonel, intercessor of the Minister of Defense, head of the military department of the army of the DPR Sergiy Petrovsky." On the advertising banner, specially prepared for the article, in capital letters, the very positive letter - "Pokhmury" is written in capital letters. The article featured a fragment of the video from "We'll Pokhmurim", in which he is a man with gray short hair and a beard, saying "to go to Kiev".

In leaf fall - one more interview, in the chest - more, and from them we know practically about all the stages of the "battle route" of "Pokhmury" before becoming the leading breeder of the "DPR": having been born in Donetsk in 1962 ( SBU) on his video stverdzhuє that in 1964, ale tsyu pardon can be written off as soon as it was prepared), having fought in Afghanistan and Chechnya, de got to know Igor Strelkov-Girkin, having served in the armies of the 30 SR of the RF and the Russian Federation .

Our earlier interview with Pokhmurim, as far as Bellingcat experts knew, was published in 2003 in the newspaper Izvestia. Todi "Pokhmury" was a colonel and served in the Caucasus, near Chechnya. "Are you fighting for Kim?" - Request yoga journalist. "Those who don't want to live in Russia according to our Russian laws, don't want to pray to our faith," Pokhmury says.
Followers of "Pokhmury" were also known on the forum and collectors forum-antikvariat.ru, de Igor Strelkov loved to write about the transfer of certificates from "Novorosiya". There, "Pokhmury" wrote under the name of the Filthy soldier. Axis of one yogo reminder (spelling and punctuation saved):
"Well, sho. decadent. now, the leaders of the representatives of Moscow. they gave my data. let me officially introduce myself - the intercessor of the Minister of Defense of the DPR for the investigation of the guards, Colonel Petrovsky Sergiy Mikolayovich.
The announcement was published on 19 June 2014, two years after the Boeing crash and one after the SBU of Ukraine published a rediscovery of Pokhmuriy's roses, stating in the video that it could be related to the "DNR intelligence".
Right in the name of that name "Pakhmury-Petrovsky" far away z'yasuvaty mayzhe vipadkovo, at the hour of the hackers' hacking of Igor Strelkov's e-mail. Fragments of yoga lists were published in May 2014 by the group of hackers "Humpty Dumpty". One of the messages addressed to Strelkov was written in the address [email protected] i looked like this:
April 28, 2014 20:27
Dubinsky Sergiy
Hello, Igor, have you forgotten the Bison yet?
This email address brought Bellingcat specialists to the side of the correspondent of the social network "My World" with the same nickname - karahan1962. There was a photograph of Petrovsky, broken, judging by the image on the city, in Afghanistan.
The mystery of the address of the electronic mail was far away to be known on the forums of veterans of the 181st motorized rifle regiment, who took part in the Afghan operation. At the virtual "roll call" of the comrades in the service in 2010, the addresses " [email protected]“I guess I’m like the one who belongs to Sergiy Dubinsky, “senior lieutenant”, “protector of the commander of the military intelligence”, who served in Afghanistan in 1985-1987, and none (in 2010 roci. - RS) lives in Donetsk. day of the people), in which all the "nick" and "positivity" of "Pakhmury-Petrovsky-Dubinsky" are refurbished:
"I be Ty, Seryoga, even "Pokhmury" at the DPR, even General "Petrovsky" or "Dvorkivsky" or the commandant of Khankali "Zubr" or "Bizon", well, or "Karahan" at Latin America, I forgot to tell you, at the pilot's, in Afghanistan, in the Karimiv greenery there was a kariz, where it was necessary to fill.
On the other side, there is a larger photo of Sergiy Mikolayovich Dubinsky - in the form of a colonel, hung with orders and medals, including awards for the war in Afghanistan. Truthfully, with a respectful look, you can remember that part of the image of the city in the photo was enhanced for the help of Photoshop, and with such medals Dubinsky did not take a moment to mother. For example, the medal "Veteran of the AP SRSR" was awarded to those who served in the Radian army for at least 25 years, and Dubinsky entered the service of more than 1984, if before the collapse of the Union there were less than 10 years left.
Once upon a time, the websites of pro-Russian separatists in the Donbas were given this front photo, as before, calling Sergius Dubinsky yogi the nickname - "Petrovsky". In one of the publications, there is a photograph of Dubinsky-Petrovsky's appointment as the "head of the DPR Rozvіdupravlіnnya", seen by the head of the so-called "people's republic" Oleksandr Zakharchenko.

The person in the photo in the uniform of a colonel is not similar to that “Pokhmury” with a short gray beard, like that photo from the “DPR” appeared on a video. Meanwhile, Dubinsky himself, on the same forum, veterans of the 181st regiment, explains it this way: “I don’t have any rozvіdgroupi. - I read the text on YouTube near the video "SPETSNAZ STRELKOVA part 1" (on this video, Dubinsky has a mass, but his voice is similar to the one that sounds on the published SBU plіvki).
In July 2016, volunteers from another group of investigators, InformNapalm, searched for more courts of Sergiy Dubinsky near the Donetsk region, near the village of Velika Novosilka, and de vin bag in 2005. On the InformNapalm website, Dubinsky's biography is described in three words of his fellow villagers as follows: 80-90 served with the Soviet Armed Forces, and during the year - with the Russian army. In 1997, roci zvіlnivsya at the reserve, he lives near the Rostov region. In 2002, a number of vocations from the reserve of personnel management in the Pivnichno-Kavkazsky district of the Russian Federation (for the current year Pivdenniy vіysk district of the Russian Federation) and referrals to the service at the warehouse of the Joint Grouping of the Military District in the Pivnichny Kavkaz. In 2004, the rozіn zvіlnivsya again and moved to the Donetsk region without a hitch (the service apartment was lost to the squad). Later, it turned out that during another transfer to the reserve, Dubinsky’s documents were ruined for an hour at the military commissariat, and formally lost his wine in the service. With whom, Dubinsky continued to receive a military pension. As a matter of fact, during the chergovіy reversal of the military part, until the turn of the century, the court praised the payment of all pennies from Sergiy Dubinsky.
The decision of the court (given, saved a copy) is about the 22nd Special Forces Brigade of the GRU of the General Staff of the Russian Federation (military unit 11659), stationed in the settlement of Stepovoi, Rostov Region. Toudi Dubinsky and having destroyed the problem with the documents that were ruined. In addition, the decision has another military part, de Dubinsky serving in the settlement of the intercessor of the commander from the vikhovna work - 51019. This military part lies up to the 116th Okremy Radio Center of the Special Appointment and is also assigned to Stepovoy.
Unexpectedly, Bellingcat researchers knew one more profile of Dubinsky - at the social network "Odnoklassniki" (at the same time, access to the new one is less for friends). From the publication of new photographs, it is clear that in 2010 Dubinsky again began to often visit or settle near the Rostov region, even though in 2011 he turned to Ukraine. In the unofficial data base of the authorities of motor transport services nomer.org there are people with such names and nicknames. Zgіdno z dannym, scho mіstyasya in nіy, vіn deysno alive with Stepovoy in the period from 1998 to 2004 rіk. Signs from Dubinsky's album in "Odnoklassniki" confirm the fact that in autumn and 2014 the fate of the wines near Donetsk - for example, being photographed with Russian actors Mikhail Porechenkov and Ivan Okhlobistinim, they came to Donbass.
In the chest photo with Oksana Arbuzova, Sergiy Dubinsky is already wearing the uniform of a major general, with a stripe, like a nadto rozmit, so that you can accurately signify belonging - you can also have a stripe for the special forces of the GRU and the land forces.
From this public record in classmates, as well as from publications on the websites of pro-Russian separatists in the Donbas, the share of Sergiy Dubinsky was also mentioned. Zvajayuchi for everything, having left the Donetsk region on the cob in 2015, I live at once near the Rostov region of Russia. From the "DPR" they drove it out with a scandal and a fence on the road: for information to the "Politnavigator" website, the reason could be a bit about those who Dubinsky "had started the Donetsk people's mines", or "the impossibility to enter the power vertical of the DPR". Uninvited on the tse, problems and illegally elevated pence yoma, it is similar, Virishiti came up: on photographers, a Dubinsky pose for Kerma, a new ATV, Vartіstyu Blizko 15,000 dovarivo, with a resort, is not a jacket for a farm. .  Bellingcat investigators and the InformNapalm group decided to designate the place of the planting of this booth - ce hutir Velykyi Log, Molodіzhna street, budinok 4a or 4b.
The authors of the investigation of the windings are: Sergiy Mykolayovich Dubinsky, vin the same Sergiy Mykolayovich Petrovsky, vin "Pokhmury" - that very person, and the very same voice on the recording of separatists' roses in France on the day of the Boeing-777 crash of the Malaysian airlines. Following the words of the authors of the investigation, a copy of the same, that all the details that were sent to Dzherel, will be forwarded to the address of the International Follow-up Group (JIT). In the fall of 2016, representatives announced that they would continue the investigation into the MH17 crash until 2018.

Viysk pensioner Sergiy Dubinsky is 54 years old. I live together with my family in the Rostov region, at a good-looking house on the farm of Veliky Log. Ride on an expensive Canadian quad bike and have a lot of ten acres. To sing-songly love the memories he passed through Afghanistan and Chechnya. The life of a human being has less than one day, about which one is unlikely to be spoken of by unknown people: July 17, 2014, the day of the Boeing-777 crash of the Malaysian Airlines near Donetsk. About tse vydchat vysnovki international preslidnitskoy group Bellingcat, presented in the rest of the world.

How to write at their own 18th line, through profit after the tragedy, as it took the lives of 298 people, the Security Service of Ukraine published a record of a telephone call, as if they were saying that the Ukrainian special services were close, close to 9 years on the 17th day. On the recording, midway through, a little voice of two people, in the credits the names of their names - "Pokhmury" and "Buryat". "Buryat" feed, kudi yoma "vantazhity beautiful", yaku vin "brought well to Donetsk". "Pokhmury" vіdpovіdaє: "Tse those, what am I thinking about?" - "So, Buk, Buk" - confirms Yogo Zdogad "Buryat". I’ll discuss even more for a sprat of khvilin “Pokhmury” with the other lieutenant, “Sanich”, where it is necessary to deliver the rocket launcher. Otrimavshi instructions, vіn robbing one more call to one of his pіdleglih: "Look at the map, Pervomaisk. Here in that area it's growing.

The caption on the video says that "Pokhmury" is really "Sergiy Mikolayovich Petrovsky, an officer of the GRU of Russia, a representative of Igor Strelkov-Girkin from the source of research."

In two years, this phone call will become one of the main pieces of evidence in the materials of the prosecutor's office of the Netherlands in the International Investigative Group about the reasons for the Boeing crash. The main version of the international group was left unchanged: they were shot down from the territory controlled by the same separatists, from the Buk-M1 rocket launcher, brought from Russia. These versions are supplemented by the authors of numerous independent investigations, and only official Moscow, having presented to the court the vast majority of dozens of mutually exclusive versions, like before, categorically rebut my accountability to tragedy.

Video of the International Follow-up Group, in which the fragments of the separatist talks scrambled by the SBU on the day of the Boeing crash:

Zavdyaki vodkritim dzherelam, we are in front of photographs and videos at social networks, at once we know about the road "Buku" from Russia to Ukraine mayzhe everything. V_domy and a number of people, one of those moments, pressed the button to launch the rocket that day. Now, as it seems, my new research independent group experts Bellingcat, in the distance, it was enough to establish the specialty of one more person, credited to the crash of the Boeing, that same Pokhmury. Їm appeared in the Russian military professional breeder Sergiy Mykolayovich Dubinsky, what a long time hovavsya for different pozivnymi and prizvyska, and also forged by the nickname "Petrovsky". Varto signify that this visnovka is grounded on one important admission: the SBU of Ukraine did not have mercy, identifying the tone of the voice on the "Pokhmury" plunkers.

In the past, after the Boeing disaster, Pokhmury appeared in the public space in the autumn of the same fate. On April 18, the pro-Kremlin website Politrussia.ru published a great interview with "Colonel, intercessor of the Minister of Defense, head of the military department of the army of the DPR Sergiy Petrovsky." On the advertising banner, specially prepared for the article, in capital letters, the very positive letter - "Pokhmury" is written in capital letters. The article featured a fragment of the video from "We'll Pokhmurim", in which he is a man with gray short hair and a beard, saying "to go to Kiev".

“I don’t have any rozvіdgroupi. The deyakі comrades confused me with the people of Slov’yanska, as I recently gave an interview and may have a similar positive. tsyumu video Dubinsky in the mass, but yogo voice is similar to the one that sounds on the published SBU plіvki.

At the end of 2016, volunteers have one more group of researchers, InformNapalm, rozshukalih susidiv Sergiy Dubinsky near the Donetsk region, near the village of Velyka Novosilka, de vin sack in 2005. On site InformNapalm Dubinsky's biography is described in words of his fellow villagers as follows: in the 80-90s he served with the Soviet Armed Forces, and in the meantime - with the Russian army. In 1997, roci zvіlnivsya at the reserve, he lives near the Rostov region. In 2002, there were a number of vocations from the reserve of personnel management in the Pivnichno-Kavkazsky military district (at the current Pivdenniy Vyysk district of Russia) and directions for the passage of service at the warehouse of the Joint Military Grouping in the Pivnichny Kavkaz. In 2004, I reborn again and moved to my mother to the Donetsk region (the service apartment was lost to the squad). Later, it turned out that during another transfer to the reserve, Dubinsky’s documents were ruined for an hour at the military commissariat, and formally lost his wine in the service. With whom, Dubinsky continued to receive a military pension. As a matter of fact, during the chergovіy reversal of the military part, until the turn of the century, the court praised the payment of all pennies from Sergiy Dubinsky.

From this public record in Odnoklassniki, as well as from publications on the websites of pro-Russian separatists in the Donbass, the share of Sergiy Dubinsky was also revealed. Zvajayuchi for everything, having left the Donetsk region on the cob in 2015, I live at once near the Rostov region of Russia. The grouping of the "DNR" was driven out with a scandal and a fence on the road: for information to the site "Politnavigator", the reason could be a little bit about those who Dubinsky "went up the mines from the Donetsk", or "impossibility to rule in the power vertical of the power of the DNR" . Uninvited on the tse, problems and illegally elevated pence yoma, it is similar, Virishiti came up: on photographers, a Dubinsky pose for Kerma, a new ATV, Vartіstyu Blizko 15,000 dovarivo, with a resort, is not a jacket for a farm. . 'Investigators Bellingcat that groupi InformNapalm far away to mark the place of roztashuvannya tsgo budinka - tse hutir the Great Log.

There is another, practically direct proof that Sergiy Mikolayovich Dubinsky may have been sent before the Buk transport to Pervomaisky, before the month, the stars of the destruction were shot at the Boeing. on the famous video Transportation of "Buk" through Makіїvka among others is visible car "Peugeot 3008".

At the forum "Global Adventure", which specializes in the discussed military conflicts and

The transportation of the Buk, according to the version of the investigation, that after crashing the MH17 flight to the Donbas, was controlled by the Russian officer Sergiy Dubinsky, who was the commander of the DPR intelligence service under the pseudonym Pokhmury

Militias on the site of the fall of the passenger plane "Malaysian Airlines" Boeing 777. 2014 (Photo: Zurab Javakhadze / TARS)

International expert-journalistic group Bellingcat, as it is engaged in a search for data for the victims, on the 15th of February presented an additional report “Who is Pokhmury: a leading major general, an indication of the fall of MH17”. The authors of the investigation identified the battle of the armed forces of the self-voted Donetsk People's Republic (DPR) Khmuriy, who was accused of transporting the launcher of the Buk missile system. Well, according to the investigations of Bellingcat, Russian officer Sergiy Dubinsky showed up.

In April 2015, JIT published phone calls of separatists, as they discussed the details of the plane crash and the transportation of the fire installation to the Buk complex. On the recording, there are distinct voices of two DPR supporters - Khmuriy (the SBU previously identified him as the intercessor of the DPR Minister of Defense Petrovsky) and Buryat. The separatists discussed the transfer of the Buk launcher to Pokhmury and the means of transporting the siege.

Investigators appointed Petrovsky's reference for the additional archive of Igor Strelkov's electronic mail, published by hackers of the "Humpty Dumpty" group. Їm so far away to see profile Dubinsky at the social network "Odnoklassniki". In the fall of 2014, Dubinsky published on his side a photo with actor Mikhail Porechenkov, who saw Donetsk from Zhovtny, and actor Ivan Okhlobistin. Later, Okhlobistin published a photograph of the birthday in his profile, giving you Pokhmury. The photograph also shows the commemoration of Major General Sergiy Petrovsky, signed by the Prime Minister of the DPR Oleksandr Zakharchenko.

Zgidno with the praise of the Aksai District Court of the Rostov Region, in April 2015, Dubinsky was awarded a Viysk pension for his service. The decree states that the officer served in military units No. 61019, No. 11659 (the 22nd division of the GRU special forces brigade) and No. 51019 (a military radio station of special recognition). The rest of the Viysk part is located near the town of Stepovy Rostov region.

Bellingcat handed over some data to the investigation team (JIT, Joint Investigation Team), as it was conducting a criminal investigation into the downing of the Boeing MH17, which was shot down in the Donetsk region in April 2014. The warehouse of this group includes representatives of the following bodies of Australia, Belgium, the Netherlands, Malaysia and Ukraine.

Bellingcat experts also sent JIT data on the activity of the 69th military brigade of the material and technical support of the Russian Armed Forces (military unit No. 11385). As the investigators say, the military servicemen took part in the transported launcher "Buk" to the Russian-Ukrainian cordon near the cherry blossoms and limes of 2014. Bellingcat took a look at the social networks and showed a large number of photographs taken near the Rostov region during the installation's transportation. On the signs, the military equipment was taken, recorded by eyewitnesses.

RBC sent an official request to the Ministry of Defense of Russia about the results of the investigation of Bellingcat. Earlier, the defense department investigated a group of accidents on the liner. At the thought of the Russian military, additional groups were inspired by “pseudo-hypotheses” and falsification of data about the MH17 disaster.

Boeing 777 of Malaysia Airlines, flying from Amsterdam to Kuala Lumpur, having experienced an accident in the sky over Donbas on 17 April 2014. On board flight MH17, 298 people were transferred, most of them were the bulk of the Netherlands. Mustaches perished.

In the spring of 2016, the JIT announced the first results of the investigation of the disaster. During the presentation, the head of the central department of criminal investigations of the National Police of the Netherlands, Wilbert Paulissen, and the Prosecutor General of the Netherlands, Fred Westerbeck, said that the Buk, for which MH17 was shot down, was delivered to the territory of the DPR from Russia.

The Russian side repeatedly twirled the JIT visnovki. In the spring of 2016, the Ministry of Defense of Russia gave tribute to the Utyos-T radar complex, which was ordered in the Rostov region. Due to an additional notice from the chief of the radio engineering military Russian airborne forces, Major General Andriy Koban, Utyos-T did not record the launch of a ground-to-air missile on the territory controlled by self-voiced republics.

The official Russian version - MH17 was shot down by a Buk launcher, but outside the territory, as if it were under the control of the Ukrainian military. As proof of the version of the 2014 version, Andriy Kartapolov, head of the head operational department of the General Staff, presented satellite images. On them, the military recorded the movement of the Buk launcher of the Ukrainian army. This version is also being submitted to the Almaz-Antey Concern. As a signatory to the concern, a rocket was launched in the area of ​​​​the village of Zaroshchenske, which, for the tribute of the Ministry of Defense of Russia, was at that time under the control of the Ukrainian army.

Bellingcat is an international journalistic expert group founded on April 15, 2014 by British journalist Eliot Higgins. Head of the team - associations of community journalists at the investigation of the current streams. Bellingcat's flagship project today is investigating the causes of the Malaysian Boeing crash. The team is also following the military campaign in Syria, including the activities of the Russian military servicemen. In its own subplots, Bellingcat revolves around dzherel's signatures: video, photo materials, placements in social networks, and satellite images. Bellingcat is based on a private donation, selected for the support of the Kickstarter crowdfunding service. The team has over two dozen people and a large number of volunteers who help the project for free.

The reliability of Bellingcat's reports was sometimes rated according to sums of foreign ZMI. The black German magazine Spiegel interviewed an expert for analyzing the ship photograph of Jens Kreise. The reason for this was the report of Bellingcat, who, for the group’s insistence, was brought to the side of the Ministry of Defense of Russia to manipulate photographs of the downed flight MH17. Kreize, stating that the method used by Bellingcat, at a glance, the experts do not see much criticism. “At its core, faults rely on the so-called ELA-analysis. This method is non-scientific and subjective. Obviously, there are many scientific articles related to the method,” he said (cited by “InoSMI.ru”). The editor-in-chief of Spiegel Online, Florian Kharms, was vehemently reprimanded by readers for those that the editors, based on information from Bellingcat, gave hard headlines about those that Russia manipulated the signs. Behind the words of Kharms, the news from Bellingcat's follow-up was given in a wise way, the shards of the statements of the contributors were not a necessary rank of revision by the editors.